Our Story
More Than a Trophy Shop.
For over 40 years, Watts Trophy Shop has been the heart of celebration in Bucyrus, Ohio. We're the people behind the trophies your kids hold up in team photos, the plaques on your office wall, and the medals your athletes wear with pride.
Since 1985
Built on Bucyrus Pride
Watts Trophy Shop started with a simple belief: every achievement deserves to be recognized. From a young athlete's first season to a 30-year employee milestone, we've been there to make those moments tangible.
Over four decades, we've grown from a small storefront into the go-to awards destination for sports leagues, schools, churches, businesses, and families across Crawford County and beyond.
We still do things the old-fashioned way — with personal service, honest pricing, and a genuine love for what we do. Come find us at 556 South Sandusky Ave in Bucyrus, or give us a call at (419) 562-8800. We'd love to help you celebrate your next win.
What We Stand For
Our Values
Community First
Bucyrus is our home. We've cheered at the same games, attended the same schools, and celebrated the same wins. When you walk through our door, you're family.
Quality You Can Feel
Every trophy, plaque, and medal we sell is something we're proud to put our name on. We don't cut corners — your award should feel as special as the achievement it represents.
Personal Service
We know our customers by name. Whether you need 5 trophies or 500, you'll get the same personal attention and care that's made us Bucyrus's trusted awards shop for over 40 years.
Shop Management Team
While the humans run the machines, these four make sure everything runs smoothly around the shop.
Preston specializes in greeting customers, supervising incoming orders, and making sure every trophy that leaves the shop has passed the official sniff test. Known for exceptional tail-wag customer service.
Phoebe keeps a watchful eye on trophy customization and engravings. While she doesn't operate the machines herself, she ensures everything meets her very high standards of excellence (and shininess).
Paisley oversees incoming shipments and outgoing deliveries. Every box is carefully inspected, sniffed, and occasionally sat on to confirm structural integrity.
Payden handles shop promotion and public relations. Frequently spotted posing for photos, greeting customers, and spreading the word that champions deserve great trophies.
Ready to work with us?
Stop in, give us a call, or send us a message. We'd love to help you celebrate your next big win.